Title: Why is the old version of Guan Yinping weak? ——Analyzing her shortcomings from data and mechanisms
In the historical version of "Three Kingdoms", Guan Yinping, as a military commander of the Shu forces, was controversial due to strength issues. This article will use the discussion data of hot topics on the entire network in the past 10 days (as of October 2023), combined with the skill mechanism and actual combat performance, to conduct a structured analysis of the reasons for the weakness of the old version of Guan Yinping.
1. Comparison of popularity data across the entire network (last 10 days)
| Topic keywords | Amount of discussions (articles) | Proportion of negative reviews |
|---|---|---|
| Guan Yinping strengthens | 1,240 | 68% |
| Old version of Guan Yinping | 892 | 83% |
| New version of Guan Yinping | 1,750 | 12% |
2. Analysis of defects in skill mechanism
Old version of Guan Yinping’s skills"Tiger Roar"and"Taketsugi"There are the following shortcomings:
| Skill name | Trigger condition | core issues |
|---|---|---|
| tiger roar | After using [Kill] to specify the target | Depends on equipment zone cards and unstable income |
| Taketsugi | When other characters die | Lagging rhythm and no immediate benefits |
3. Actual performance data
The winning rate data of the old version according to player community statistics (sample size 5,000 games):
| model | attendance rate | winning rate | Comparison of generals of the same grade |
|---|---|---|---|
| identity field | 3.2% | 41.7% | 9.3% below average |
| 2v2 competition | 1.8% | 38.1% | 7th from the bottom among all generals |
4. Summary of core reasons for weakness
1.Poor skill linkage: Tiger Roar needs equipment support, but Wuji cannot provide the means to obtain equipment.
2.Serious revenue delays: Wu Ji requires the death of his teammates to trigger, which goes against the fast-paced environment.
3.numerically conservative: Tiger Roar's checking/damage effect is lower than that of generals of the same period (such as Jie Zhang Liao)
4.Blurred positioning: Neither powerful output, nor lacking defense or auxiliary capabilities
5. Player improvement suggestions high-frequency word cloud
| Suggestion type | frequency of occurrence | Representative plan |
|---|---|---|
| Skill reworked | 647 times | Wu Ji changed to active skill |
| numerical improvement | 512 times | Tiger roar damage +1 |
| Mechanism optimization | 389 times | Increase equipment search effect |
It is worth noting that the new version of Guan Yinping passed"Tiger Roar" has been changed to a limited skill,"Wu Ji" increases active effectWith the changes, the strength has been significantly improved. This proves the design flaws of the old version. The balance of generals needs to take into account both historical fit and gameplay. Overly conservative skill designs will eventually be eliminated by the version.
check the details
check the details
en
